Know Your Rights
No attorney can replace the value of you knowing your rights and asserting them from the beginning to the end of a police contact.
Police may try to convince you that cooperating with them will result in some sort of leniency, but this is a lie.
It will only get you into more trouble by helping the police build a case against you.
Whether you are a citizen of the United States or not, or if whether you are an adult or minor, you have the same constitutional rights. Click on your rights below to educate yourself about what you do NOT have to do in interactions with the police. Asserting your rights during police contacts is the most powerful tool you have to win your case before your ever get to court.
THE RIGHT TO WALK AWAY
Ask “am I free to leave?” when police approach you and start to talk with you. When police prevent you from leaving, you are detained and “seized” under the Fourth Amendment. Before police can detain you, they must have “reasonable suspicion” that you are involved in criminal activity.
If police tell you that you are NOT free to leave or confirm that you are being detained, you must comply. But if they indicate that staying with them is optional, you are free to leave and you can (and should) walk away.
THE RIGHT TO REMAIN SILENT
Many cases would not be provable if the suspect had refused to speak with police. The Fifth Amendment’s privilege against self-incrimination guarantees that you ALWAYS have the right to refuse to speak with police and doing so cannot be used against you. Police will convince you that talking with them will help you, that they want to hear your side of the story, that they already know what happened so refusing to tell the truth only makes you look bad, etc. ( It is illegal for police to make any sort of promise or threat to get you to talk to them about a crime, by the way, but it is rare for a judge to throw out a confession by finding police coerced it with promises or threats.)
Your best option in the vast majority of police contacts is to clearly assert your Fifth Amendment rights from the beginning. You can say, “I do not wish to speak with you,” “I am asserting my right to remain silent,” or “I want a lawyer.”
THE RIGHT TO REFUSE TO BE SEARCHED WITHOUT A WARRANT
Police cannot search you without a warrant, unless an exception to the 4th Amendment warrant requirement exists. You NEVER have to give consent to search. If police ever ask to search you, say “no” or “I do not consent to being searched.” Also, do not tell police that you have something on you when they are about to search you, or this could justify the search and cause you to lose your suppression motion.
Some common exceptions when police can search you without your consent or a warrant include:
- Pat Search: If police have a legitimate reason to detain you, they can pat down the outside of your clothing with flat hands if they have “specific and articulable facts that you are ARMED AND DANGEROUS.” The fact that you were wearing baggy clothing and looked nervous is not enough.
- Search Incident to Arrest: Police can complete a full search of your pockets and bags you are carrying if they are arresting you. They can do this search before they cuff you if they are in fact going to arrest you, but if they do not actually intend to place you under arrest, the search is illegal. For example, if an officer is going to issue a citation rather than placing you in handcuffs and taking you to jail, he cannot complete a full search incident to arrest of your clothing and bags you are carrying.
- Probation Search: If you are on probation, particularly for a felony or weapons or drug misdemeanor offense, you have likelky given up your 4th Amedment right to be free from warrantless searches. Police cannot search you pursuant to your probation terms, however, if they are not aware of your search terms. If they stop and search you for no good reason but find out later that you had probation search terms, the search is still illegal and the evidence should be suppressed.
Top 10 Know Your Rights FAQ’s
1. Can my case get thrown out if the police never read me my Miranda rights?
Sometimes. Police only have to read your Miranda rights if you are under arrest and being questioned. If they fail to do so, your statements may be excluded from evidence. In some cases, that can lead to charges being dismissed.
2. Can police search my house without showing me the search warrant?
Yes. Police generally need a valid warrant or a legal exception to search your home, but they are not required to show you the warrant before entering. They must, however, comply with knock-and-notice requirements.
3. Can police use my face to unlock my phone without my permission?
Yes, if they have a warrant. Police cannot force you to reveal your passcode, which is why using a numeric or alphanumeric code provides greater protection than facial recognition.
4. Do police have to tell me why I am being detained?
No. Officers are not required to explain the reason immediately, but they must later justify the detention in court and cannot prolong the stop beyond what is reasonably necessary.
5. Are "pretext" traffic stops illegal?
Sometimes. Although pretext stops are generally allowed under federal law, California's Racial Justice Act may provide legal challenges when racial profiling played a role.
6. Do I have to identify myself when police ask for my name?
If you are lawfully detained, officers may ask for your identification. Drivers must present a driver's license. After an arrest, you are required to identify yourself during booking.
7. Can I challenge evidence found during an illegal search of someone else's property?
No. Fourth Amendment protections are personal. You generally cannot suppress evidence based on a violation of another person's constitutional rights.
8. Can police search my car during a traffic stop?
Usually not. Officers typically need probable cause, a legitimate officer-safety concern, or a lawful arrest that justifies a vehicle search under the circumstances.
9. Is it legal for police to lie to me during questioning?
For adults, yes. Police may legally use deception during interrogations. The safest approach is to remain silent and request an attorney before answering questions.
10. Do I ever have to consent to a search?
No. You should comply with lawful commands, but you never have to voluntarily consent to a search. Politely declining preserves your legal rights.
Her skills in depositions, trial work, and cross-examination are outstanding and she knows exactly how to elicit the right testimony. She fought for me during an especially difficult situation, where my ex was involved with his attorney — something that complicated the dynamics significantly.
Her balanced approach between litigation and settlement is rare and invaluable. Since my case was transferred to her, not only did I feel more protected legally, but my mental health significantly improved as well.
If you are looking for someone who will truly stand by you, advocate for truth, and handle even the most complex situations with skill and compassion, I can’t recommend Hali enough.
Do not settle for an attorney looking for the easiest way to settle your case.
PROUDLY SERVING
Ventura County
We proudly represent clients in every city and community across Ventura County.
Know Your Rights — California Detailed Guide
Your Miranda Rights
Under Miranda v. Arizona, 384 U.S. 436 (1966), law enforcement must advise you of specific rights before custodial interrogation: (1) you have the right to remain silent; (2) anything you say can be used against you in court; (3) you have the right to an attorney; (4) if you cannot afford an attorney, one will be appointed. Miranda applies only when you are (a) in custody and (b) being interrogated. Volunteered statements are admissible. If police fail to Mirandize you and you speak, statements typically cannot be used in the prosecution’s case-in-chief.
Fourth Amendment — Search and Seizure
The Fourth Amendment protects against unreasonable searches and seizures. Warrantless searches are presumptively unreasonable unless an exception applies (consent, search incident to arrest, exigent circumstances, plain view, automobile exception, protective sweep, or inventory search). You have the right to refuse consent to a search of your home, vehicle, or person. Refusing consent alone is not probable cause. Police need reasonable suspicion for an investigatory stop and probable cause for an arrest.
Right to Counsel
Under the Sixth Amendment (adopted in California via case law and the state constitution), you have the right to an attorney at critical stages of criminal proceedings — including custodial interrogation once invoked, arraignment, preliminary hearing, plea negotiations, trial, and sentencing. In juvenile cases, WIC 634 provides similar counsel rights. If you say clearly “I want a lawyer” during interrogation, questioning must stop.
Right to Remain Silent
You do not have to answer police questions beyond identifying yourself in appropriate circumstances (California is a “stop-and-identify” state only in limited situations). Silence generally cannot be used against you as evidence of guilt (though this doctrine has narrow exceptions). The best practice is a clear, polite invocation: “I am exercising my right to remain silent and I want to speak with a lawyer.”
DUI-Specific Rights
Under California’s implied-consent law (Vehicle Code Section 23612), by driving in California you consent to a chemical test (breath or blood) if lawfully arrested for DUI. Refusing carries automatic license suspension (1 year for a first refusal) and enhanced penalties on conviction. Preliminary Alcohol Screening (PAS) tests at the roadside are generally voluntary for drivers over 21 who are not on DUI probation. Field sobriety tests are also voluntary.
Family Court Rights
In family court, both parties have the right to notice and an opportunity to be heard before orders that affect their rights. In domestic-violence restraining-order proceedings, respondents have the right to a full evidentiary hearing before permanent orders. Under Family Code Section 3044, a recent DV finding creates a rebuttable presumption against custody. In juvenile dependency and delinquency cases, parents and minors have specific procedural rights under the Welfare and Institutions Code.
See related: criminal defense, family law, juvenile law, ways to win your case. External resources: ACLU of Northern California — Know Your Rights, and California Courts self-help.
Questions about your specific situation? 805-853-FREE or contact us for a free consultation.